 Gerry McNeil G
Montreal Canadiens
|  Dickie Moore LW
Montreal Canadiens
Lucky Premium Back
|  Jean Beliveau C
Montreal Canadiens
|  Eddie Mazur LW
Montreal Canadiens
|
 Bert Olmstead RW
Montreal Canadiens
|  Butch Bouchard D
Montreal Canadiens
|  Maurice Richard RW
Montreal Canadiens
2nd Team All Star RW
|  Bernie Geoffrion
Montreal Canadiens
|
 John McCormack C
Montreal Canadiens
|  Tom Johnson D
Montreal Canadiens
|  Calum MacKay LW
Montreal Canadiens
|  Kenny Mosdell C
Montreal Canadiens
1rst Team All Star C
|
 Paul Masnick C
Montreal Canadiens
|  Doug Harvey D
Montreal Canadiens
1rst Team All Star D
|  Floyd Curry RW
Montreal Canadiens
Lucky Premium Back
|  Harry Lumley G
Toronto Maple Leafs
1rst Team All Star G
|
 Harry Watson LW
Toronto Maple Leafs
|  Jim Morrison D
Toronto Maple Leafs
Lucky Premium Back
|  Eric Nesterenko RW
Toronto Maple Leafs
|  Fernie Flaman D
Toronto Maple Leafs
Lucky Premium Back
|
 Rudy Migay C
Toronto Maple Leafs
|  Sid Smith LW
Toronto Maple Leafs
Lucky Premium Back
|  Ron Stewart RW
Toronto Maple Leafs
|  George Armstrong RW
Toronto Maple Leafs
|
 Earl Balfour LW
Toronto Maple Leafs
|  Leo Labine D
Toronto Maple Leafs
Lucky Premium Back
|  Gord Hannigan C
Toronto Maple Leafs
Lucky Premium Back
|  Bob Bailey C
Toronto Maple Leafs
|
 Ted Kennedy C
Toronto Maple Leafs
2nd Team All Star C
|  Tod Sloan C
Toronto Maple Leafs
|  Tim Horton D
Toronto Maple Leafs
2nd Team All Star D
|  Jim Thompson D
Toronto Maple Leafs
|
 Terry Sawchuk G
Detroit Red Wings
2nd Team All Star G
|  Marcel Pronovost D
Detroit Red Wings
|  Metro Prystai C
Detroit Red Wings
|  Alex Delvecchio C
Detroit Red Wings
|
 Earl Reibel C
Detroit Red Wings
|  Benny Woit D
Detroit Red Wings
|  Bob Goldham D
Detroit Red Wings
|  Glen Skov C
Detroit Red Wings
Lucky Premium Back
|
