1
Harvey White QB
Boston Patriots
| 
2
Corky Tharp HB
New York Titans
| 
3
Dan McGrew C
Buffalo Bills
| 
4
Bob White FB
Houston Oilers
| 
5
Dick Jamieson QB
Dallas Texans
| 
6
Sam Salerno T
Denver Broncos
|
7
Sid Gilman Coach
Los Angeles Chargers (Rookie card)
| 
8
Ben Preston E
Los Angeles Chargers
| 
9
George Branch
Oakland Raiders
| 
10
Bob Stransky HB
Denver Broncos
| 
11
Fran Curci QB
Dallas Texans
| 
12
George Shirkey T
Houston Oilers
|
13
Paul Larson QB
Oakland Raiders
| 
14
John Stolte T
Los Angeles Chargers
| 
15
Serafino Fazio C
Boston Patriots
| 
16
Tom Dimitroff QB
New York Titans
| 
17
Elbert Dubenion HB
Buffalo Bills
| 
18
Hogan Wharton G
Houston Oilers
|
19
Tommy O'Connell QB
Buffalo Bills
| 
20
Sammy Baugh Coach
New York Titans
| 
21
Tony Sardisco G
Boston Patriots
| 
22
Alan Cann FB
Boston Patriots
| 
23
Mike Hudock C
New York Titans
| 
24
Bill Atkins HB
Buffalo Bills
|
25
Charlie Jackson HB
Dallas Texans
| 
26
Frank Tripucka QB
Denver Broncos
| 
27
Tony Teresa QB
Oakland Raiders
| 
28
Joe Amstutz C
Los Angeles Chargers
| 
29
Bob Fee FB
Boston Patriots
| 
30
Jim Baldwin C
New York Titans
|
31
Jim Yates E
Houston Oilers
| 
32
Don Flynn QB
Dallas Texans
| 
33
Ken Adamson G
Denver Broncos
| 
34
Ron Orzewiecki B
Oakland Raiders
| 
35
J.W. Black HB
Los Angeles Chargers
| 
36
Bob Yates T
Boston Patriots
|
37
Gary Cobb G
Buffalo Bills
| 
38
Jack Lee QB
Houston Oilers
| 
39
Jack Spikes FB
Dallas Texans
| 
40
Jim Padgett T
Denver Broncos
| 
41
Jack Larsheid B
Oakland Raiders
| 
42
Bob Reifsnyder DE
Los Angeles Chargers
|
43
Fran Rogel FB
New York Titans
| 
44
Ray Moss LB
Buffalo Bills
| 
45
Tony Banfield HB
Houston Oilers
| 
46
George Herring QB
Denver Broncos
| 
47
Willie Smith T
Denver Broncos
| 
48
Buddy Allen HB
Oakland Raiders
|
49
Bill Brown C
Boston Patriots
| 
50
Kenneth Ford QB
New York Titans
| 
51
Billy Kinard HB
Buffalo Bills
| 
52
Buddy Mayfield E
Houston Oilers
| 
53
Bill Krishner G
Dallas Texans
| 
54
Frank Bernardi HB
Denver Broncos
|
55
Lou Saban Coach
Boston Patriots
| 
56
Gene Cockrell G
New York Titans
| 
57
Sam Sanders LB
Buffalo Bills
| 
58
George Blanda QB
Houston Oilers
| 
59
Sherrill Headrick LB
Dallas Texans
| 
60
Carl Larpenter G
Denver Broncos
|
61
Gene Prebola E
Oakland Raiders
| 
62
Dick Chorovich T
Los Angeles Chargers
| 
63
Bob McNamara HB
Boston Patriots
| 
64
Tom Saidock T
New York Titans
| 
65
Willie Evans HB
Buffalo Bills
| 
66
Billy Cannon HB
Houston Oilers (Rookie card)
|
67
Sam McCord QB
Oakland Raiders
| 
68
Mike Simmons E
New York Titans
| 
69
Jim Swink HB
Dallas Texans
| 
70
Don Hitt C
Houston Oilers
| 
71
Ger Schwedes HB
Boston Patriots
| 
72
Thurlow Cooper E
New York Titans
|
73
Abner Haynes HB
(1960 AFL MVP)
Dallas Texans
| 
74
Billy Shoemake E
Denver Broncos
| 
75
Marv Lasater B
Oakland Raiders
| 
76
Paul Lowe HB
Los Angeles Chargers
| 
77
Bruce Hartman T
Boston Patriots
| 
78
Blanche Martin HB
New York Titans
|
79
Gene Grabosky T
Buffalo Bills
| 
80
Lou Rymkus Coach
Houston Oilers
| 
81
Chris Burford E
Dallas Texans
| 
82
Don Allen FB
Denver Broncos
| 
83
Bob Nelson C
Oakland Raiders
| 
84
Jim Woodard T
Oakland Raiders
|
85
Tom Rychlec DE
Buffalo Bills
| 
86
Bob Cox HB
Boston Patriots
| 
87
Jerry Cornelison G
Dallas Texans
| 
88
Jack Work HB
Denver Broncos
| 
89
Sam DeLuca T
Los Angeles Chargers
| 
90
Rommie Loudd LB
Los Angeles Chargers
|
91
Teddy Edmondson G
New York Titans
| 
92
Buster Ramsey Coach
Buffalo Bills
| 
93
Doug Asad E
Houston Oilers
| 
94
Jimmy Harris DB
Dallas Texans
| 
95
Larry Cundiff C
Denver Broncos
| 
96
Richie Lucas QB
Buffalo Bills
|
97
Don Norwood E
Boston Patriots
| 
98
Larry Grantham E
New York Titans
| 
99
Bill Mathis HB
Houston Oilers
| 
100
Mel Branch E
Dallas Texans
| 
101
Marvin Terrell G
Dallas Texans
| 
102
Charlie Flowers FB
Los Angeles Chargers
|
103
John McMullan G
New York Titans
| 
104
Charles Kaaihue G
Oakland Raiders
| 
105
Joe Schaffer T
Buffalo Bills
| 
106
Al Day FB
Denver Broncos
| 
107
John Carson E
Houston Oilers
| 
108
Alan Goldstein E
Oakland Raiders
|
109
Doug Cline FB
Houston Oilers
| 
110
Al Carmichael HB
Denver Broncos
| 
111
Bob Dee E
Boston Patriots
| 
112
John Bredice E
New York Titans
| 
113
Don Floyd E
Houston Oilers
| 
114
Ronnie Cain E
Denver Broncos
|
115
Stan Flowers HB
Boston Patriots
| 
116
Hank Stram Coach
Dallas Texans (Rookie card)
| 
117
Bob Dougherty LB
Oakland Raiders
| 
118
Ron Mix T
Los Angeles Chargers (Rookie card)
| 
119
Roger Ellis C
New York Titans
| 
120
Elvin Caldwell HB
Boston Patriots
|
121
Bill Kimber E
Los Angeles Chargers
| 
122
Jim Matheny LB
Houston Oilers
| 
123
Curley Johnson HB
Dallas Texans
| 
124
Jack Kemp QB
Los Angeles Chargers (Rookie card)
| 
125
Ed Denk G
Boston Patriots
| 
126
Jerry McFarland T
New York Titans
|
127
Dan Lanphear E
Houston Oilers
| 
128
Paul McGuire E
Los Angeles Chargers (Rookie card)
| 
129
Ray Collins T
Dallas Texans
| 
130
Ron Burton HB
Boston Patriots
| 
131
Eddie Erdelatz Coach
Oakland Raiders
| 
132
Ron Beagle E
Oakland Raiders
|
