 1 Harvey White QB Boston Patriots
|  2 Corky Tharp HB New York Titans
|  3 Dan McGrew C Buffalo Bills
|  4 Bob White FB Houston Oilers
|  5 Dick Jamieson QB Dallas Texans
|  6 Sam Salerno T Denver Broncos
|
 7 Sid Gilman Coach Los Angeles Chargers (Rookie card)
|  8 Ben Preston E Los Angeles Chargers
|  9 George Branch Oakland Raiders
|  10 Bob Stransky HB Denver Broncos
|  11 Fran Curci QB Dallas Texans
|  12 George Shirkey T Houston Oilers
|
 13 Paul Larson QB Oakland Raiders
|  14 John Stolte T Los Angeles Chargers
|  15 Serafino Fazio C Boston Patriots
|  16 Tom Dimitroff QB New York Titans
|  17 Elbert Dubenion HB Buffalo Bills
|  18 Hogan Wharton G Houston Oilers
|
 19 Tommy O'Connell QB Buffalo Bills
|  20 Sammy Baugh Coach New York Titans
|  21 Tony Sardisco G Boston Patriots
|  22 Alan Cann FB Boston Patriots
|  23 Mike Hudock C New York Titans
|  24 Bill Atkins HB Buffalo Bills
|
 25 Charlie Jackson HB Dallas Texans
|  26 Frank Tripucka QB Denver Broncos
|  27 Tony Teresa QB Oakland Raiders
|  28 Joe Amstutz C Los Angeles Chargers
|  29 Bob Fee FB Boston Patriots
|  30 Jim Baldwin C New York Titans
|
 31 Jim Yates E Houston Oilers
|  32 Don Flynn QB Dallas Texans
|  33 Ken Adamson G Denver Broncos
|  34 Ron Orzewiecki B Oakland Raiders
|  35 J.W. Black HB Los Angeles Chargers
|  36 Bob Yates T Boston Patriots
|
 37 Gary Cobb G Buffalo Bills
|  38 Jack Lee QB Houston Oilers
|  39 Jack Spikes FB Dallas Texans
|  40 Jim Padgett T Denver Broncos
|  41 Jack Larsheid B Oakland Raiders
|  42 Bob Reifsnyder DE Los Angeles Chargers
|
 43 Fran Rogel FB New York Titans
|  44 Ray Moss LB Buffalo Bills
|  45 Tony Banfield HB Houston Oilers
|  46 George Herring QB Denver Broncos
|  47 Willie Smith T Denver Broncos
|  48 Buddy Allen HB Oakland Raiders
|
 49 Bill Brown C Boston Patriots
|  50 Kenneth Ford QB New York Titans
|  51 Billy Kinard HB Buffalo Bills
|  52 Buddy Mayfield E Houston Oilers
|  53 Bill Krishner G Dallas Texans
|  54 Frank Bernardi HB Denver Broncos
|
 55 Lou Saban Coach Boston Patriots
|  56 Gene Cockrell G New York Titans
|  57 Sam Sanders LB Buffalo Bills
|  58 George Blanda QB Houston Oilers
|  59 Sherrill Headrick LB Dallas Texans
|  60 Carl Larpenter G Denver Broncos
|
 61 Gene Prebola E Oakland Raiders
|  62 Dick Chorovich T Los Angeles Chargers
|  63 Bob McNamara HB Boston Patriots
|  64 Tom Saidock T New York Titans
|  65 Willie Evans HB Buffalo Bills
|  66 Billy Cannon HB Houston Oilers (Rookie card)
|
 67 Sam McCord QB Oakland Raiders
|  68 Mike Simmons E New York Titans
|  69 Jim Swink HB Dallas Texans
|  70 Don Hitt C Houston Oilers
|  71 Ger Schwedes HB Boston Patriots
|  72 Thurlow Cooper E New York Titans
|
 73 Abner Haynes HB (1960 AFL MVP) Dallas Texans
|  74 Billy Shoemake E Denver Broncos
|  75 Marv Lasater B Oakland Raiders
|  76 Paul Lowe HB Los Angeles Chargers
|  77 Bruce Hartman T Boston Patriots
|  78 Blanche Martin HB New York Titans
|
 79 Gene Grabosky T Buffalo Bills
|  80 Lou Rymkus Coach Houston Oilers
|  81 Chris Burford E Dallas Texans
|  82 Don Allen FB Denver Broncos
|  83 Bob Nelson C Oakland Raiders
|  84 Jim Woodard T Oakland Raiders
|
 85 Tom Rychlec DE Buffalo Bills
|  86 Bob Cox HB Boston Patriots
|  87 Jerry Cornelison G Dallas Texans
|  88 Jack Work HB Denver Broncos
|  89 Sam DeLuca T Los Angeles Chargers
|  90 Rommie Loudd LB Los Angeles Chargers
|
 91 Teddy Edmondson G New York Titans
|  92 Buster Ramsey Coach Buffalo Bills
|  93 Doug Asad E Houston Oilers
|  94 Jimmy Harris DB Dallas Texans
|  95 Larry Cundiff C Denver Broncos
|  96 Richie Lucas QB Buffalo Bills
|
 97 Don Norwood E Boston Patriots
|  98 Larry Grantham E New York Titans
|  99 Bill Mathis HB Houston Oilers
|  100 Mel Branch E Dallas Texans
|  101 Marvin Terrell G Dallas Texans
|  102 Charlie Flowers FB Los Angeles Chargers
|
 103 John McMullan G New York Titans
|  104 Charles Kaaihue G Oakland Raiders
|  105 Joe Schaffer T Buffalo Bills
|  106 Al Day FB Denver Broncos
|  107 John Carson E Houston Oilers
|  108 Alan Goldstein E Oakland Raiders
|
 109 Doug Cline FB Houston Oilers
|  110 Al Carmichael HB Denver Broncos
|  111 Bob Dee E Boston Patriots
|  112 John Bredice E New York Titans
|  113 Don Floyd E Houston Oilers
|  114 Ronnie Cain E Denver Broncos
|
 115 Stan Flowers HB Boston Patriots
|  116 Hank Stram Coach Dallas Texans (Rookie card)
|  117 Bob Dougherty LB Oakland Raiders
|  118 Ron Mix T Los Angeles Chargers (Rookie card)
|  119 Roger Ellis C New York Titans
|  120 Elvin Caldwell HB Boston Patriots
|
 121 Bill Kimber E Los Angeles Chargers
|  122 Jim Matheny LB Houston Oilers
|  123 Curley Johnson HB Dallas Texans
|  124 Jack Kemp QB Los Angeles Chargers (Rookie card)
|  125 Ed Denk G Boston Patriots
|  126 Jerry McFarland T New York Titans
|
 127 Dan Lanphear E Houston Oilers
|  128 Paul McGuire E Los Angeles Chargers (Rookie card)
|  129 Ray Collins T Dallas Texans
|  130 Ron Burton HB Boston Patriots
|  131 Eddie Erdelatz Coach Oakland Raiders
|  132 Ron Beagle E Oakland Raiders
|