1 Eddie Le Baron Washington Redskins
| 2 John Dottley Chicago Bears
| 3 Vito "Babe" Parilli Green Bay Packers
| 4 "Bucko" Kilroy Philadelphia Eagles
| 5 Joe Tereshinski Washington Redskins
| 6 Doak Walker Detroit Lions
|
7 Francis Polsfoot Chicago Cardinals
| 8 Sisto Averno Baltimore Colts
| 9 Marion Motley RB Cleveland Browns
| 10 Pat Brady Pittsburgh Steelers
| 11 Norm Van Brocklin QB Los Angeles Rams
| 12 William Mc Coll Chicago Bears
|
13 Jerry Groom Chicago Cardinals
| 14 Alfred Pollard Philadelphia Eagles
| 15 Dante Lavelli Cleveland Browns
| 16 Eddie Price New York Giants
| 17 Charley Trippi Chicago Cardinals
| 18 Elbie Nickel Pittsburgh Steelers
|
19 George Taliaferro Baltimore Colts
| 20 Charley Conerly New York Giants
| 21 Bobby Layne QB Detroit Lions
| 22 Elroy Hirsch Los Angeles Rams
| 23 James Finks Pittsburgh Steelers
| 24 "Chuck" Bednarik Philadelphia Eagles
|
25 Kyle Rote New York Giants
| 26 Otto Graham QB Cleveland Browns
| 27 Harry Gilmer Washington Redskins
| 28 Tobin Rote Green Bay Packers
| 29 Billy Stone Chicago Bears
| 30 Buddy Young Baltimore Colts
|
31 Leon Hart Detroit Lions
| 32 Hugh McElhenny San Francisco 49ers
| 33 Dale Samuels Chicago Cardinals
| 34 Lou Creekmur Detroit Lions
| 35 Tom Catlin Cleveland Browns
| 36 Tom Fears Los Angeles Rams
|
37 George Connor Chicago Bears
| 38 Bill Walsh Pittsburgh Steelers
| 39 Leo Sanford Chicago Cardinals
| 40 Horace Gillom Cleveland Browns
| 41 John Schweder Pittsburgh Steelers
| 42 Tom O'Connell Chicago Bears
|
43 Frank Gifford RB New York Giants
| 44 Frank Continetti Baltimore Colts
| 45 John Olszewski Chicago Cardinals
| 46 William "Dub" Jones Cleveland Browns
| 47 Don Paul Los Angeles Rams
| 48 Gerald Weatherly Chicago Bears
|
49 Fred Bruney Cleveland Browns
| 50 John Scarbath Washington Redskins
| 51 John Karras Chicago Cardinals
| 52 Alfred Conway Philadelphia Eagles
| 53 Emlen Tunnell New York Giants
| 54 Gern Nagler Baltimore Colts
|
55 Ken Snyder Philadelphia Eagles
| 56 Y.A. Tittle QB San Francisco 49ers
| 57 John Rapacz New York Giants
| 58 Harry Sewell Detroit Lions
| 59 Don Bingham Chicago Bears
| 60 Darrell Hogan Pittsburgh Steelers
|
61 Tony Curcillo Chicago Cardinals
| 62 Ray Renfro Cleveland Browns
| 63 Leon Heath Washington Redskins
| 64 De Witt Coulter New York Giants
| 65 Dewayne Douglas New York Giants
| 66 Robert Smith Detroit Lions
|
67 Bob McChesney New York Giants
| 68 Dick Alban Washington Redskins
| 69 Andy Kozar Chicago Bears
| 70 Merwin Hodel New York Giants
| 71 Thurman McGraw Detroit Lions
| 72 Cliff Anderson Chicago Cardinals
|
73 Pete Pihos Philadelphia Eagles
| 74 Jules Rykovich Washington Redskins
| 75 John Kreamcheck Chicago Bears
| 76 Lynn Chandnois Pittsburgh Steelers
| 77 Cloyce Box Detroit Lions
| 78 Ray Mathews Pittsburgh Steelers
|
79 Bob Walston Philadelphia Eagles
| 80 Jim Dooley Chicago Bears
| 81 Pat Harder Detroit Lions
| 82 Jerry Shipkey Pittsburgh Steelers
| 83 Bob Thomason Philadelphia Eagles
| 84 Hugh Taylor Washington Redskins
|
85 George Ratterman Cleveland Browns
| 86 Don Stonesifer Chicago Cardinals
| 87 John Williams Washington Redskins
| 88 Leo Nomellini San Francisco 49ers
| 89 Frank Ziegler Philadelphia Eagles
| 90 Don Paul Chicago Cardinals
|
91 Tom Dublinski Baltimore Colts
| 92 Ken Carpenter Cleveland Browns
| 93 Ted Marchibroda Pittsburgh Steelers
| 94 "Chuck" Drazenovich Washington Redskins
| 95 Lou Groza Cleveland Browns
| 96 "Little Billy" Cross Chicago Cardinals
|