 N172 Anson, Adrian "Cap" 11-1 HOF
|  N172 Beckley, Jake 25-4 HOF
|  N172 Brouthers, Dan 43-2 HOF
|  N172 Clarkson, John 78-4 HOF
|
 N172 Comiskey, Charles 86-1 Brown's Champions HOF
|  N172 Connor, Roger 88-1 HOF
|  N172 Delehanty, Ed 123-1 HOF
|  N172 Duffy, Hugh 135-5 HOF
|
 N172 Ewing, "Buck" 149-11 (mascot-Willie Breslin)
|  N172 Galvin, Pud
|  N172 Griffith, Clark 201-4 HOF
|  N172 Hamilton, "Sliding" Billy 210-4 HOF
|
 N172 Hanlon, Ned 212-3 HOF
|  N172 Keefe, Tim 251-3 HOF
|  N172 Kelly, Mike "King" 254-3 HOF ($10,000 Kelly)
|  N172 Mack, Connie 285-3 HOF
|
 N172 McCarthy, Tommy 301-2 HOF
|  N172 McPhee, "Bid" 317-3 HOF
|  N172 Nichols, Kid
|  N172 O'Rourke, "Orator Jim" 358-2 HOF
|
 N172 Radourn, "Hoss" 377-3 HOF
|  N172 Robinson, Wilbert "Uncle Robbie" 388-2 HOF
|  N172 Rusie, Amos 395-4 HOF
|  N172 Thompson, "Big Sam" 456-1 HOF
|
 N172 Ward, John "Monte" 478-1 HOF
|  N172 Welch, "Smiling Mickey" 486-3 HOF
|  N172 White , "Deacon"
|  N172 Wright, Harry
|